We Had an Air Dry Clay Date Night at Home and Now There Are Two Handmade Cat Trays Living in My Kitchen
I’m going to tell you about the date night where my husband — who has never once expressed interest in crafting anything — spent two focused, passionate hours making the most perfect little clay paw tray you’ve ever seen. Wine glass still half full. Cheese plate mostly untouched. Completely in the zone.
I did not see that coming. And now we have two handmade trinket trays sitting in our kitchen that we made with our own hands from our air dry clay date night on a random Saturday, and every time I walk past them I smile a little. Objects that have a story in them just hit differently.
Shop This Post
*This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
How This Date Night Came Together
We wanted a stay-home date that felt like an actual experience — not just another movie night on the couch. I’d been curious about air dry clay for a while (I’m a crafter, this was always going to happen eventually) and it felt like something we could genuinely do together without either of us needing prior skills.
I ordered everything from Amazon, set up our dining table with a cutting mat, tools, wax paper, and a block of clay, and put on the Café Society soundtrack. We opened a bottle of wine, put together a cheese board, and just… started making things.
Two hours later we had finished our trays and our wine glasses were still half full. That never happens. We were just that into it.
What You Actually Need for an Air Dry Clay Date Night (And What You Can Skip) for Beginners
You need three things: a sponge for smoothing, a cutter or slicer, and a rolling pin. That’s genuinely it for a first project. Everything else in the tool kits is nice to have depending on what you’re making, but those three will get you through most beginner projects cleanly.
I bought a full tool kit because I wanted us to have options and I didn’t know what we’d need going in. No regrets — it’s about $20 and covers everything. But if you just want to try it once, those three tools are your essentials.
For the surface, I used wax paper to keep the clay from sticking and it works really well — with one tip I’ll get to in a minute. A cutting mat is useful if you’re doing a lot of precise cutting with a knife, but we didn’t end up needing ours much. Optional for most projects.
For clay I used Crayola Air Dry Clay in Natural White — beginner friendly, easy to work with, and widely available. I bought a 5lb block for $13 and we used maybe half a pound between the two of us. You will have clay for a long time.
Oh and don’t forget the date night part. Music, wine, and cheese.
The Making (The Best Part)
We decided pretty quickly we were both going cat-themed because obviously.
I made a cat face shaped tray — round with cat ears shaped into the rim. I painted it orange, yellow, and brown afterward and I’m just going to be honest with you: it looks a little bit like toast from afar. A very cute, intentional piece of toast. I love it.
My husband made a paw print tray and genuinely surprised me. The man was passionate about this paw tray. It came out beautifully and I will not be taking questions about which one of us is more talented.
The molding process is way more fun than you expect. There’s something about working with your hands, music on, wine nearby — it’s meditative and engaging at the same time. We talked and laughed and enjoyed each other’s company. Highly recommend it as a date for that reason alone.
One tip I wish I’d known: don’t leave the clay sitting on wax paper for too long. The moisture from the clay eventually gets into the paper and it starts to stick. My husband’s tray had a small paper situation — not a disaster, quick fix, genuinely funny in the moment — but easily avoided if you transfer the piece to a fresh sheet before it sits too long.
How Long Does Air Dry Clay Take to Dry?
Fully air dry: about 2 days at room temperature. We transferred our trays to a fresh sheet of wax paper and left them on the counter. By day two they were firm, solid, and ready to paint.
Don’t rush this step. Painting on clay that isn’t fully dry will affect how the paint absorbs.
The Finishing Session (Also Very Satisfying)
Two days later we spent about 30 minutes painting — I used Winsor & Newton acrylic paint which I already had from other projects. It’s my go-to for acrylics and the pigment is really strong. If you’re buying paint specifically for this, it’s worth the investment at around $28 for a set — you’ll use it for way more than clay.
Paint dried in about 30 minutes, then we applied the Lockmio glaze which seals everything and makes the trays fully waterproof. Once the glaze is dry your piece is done, sealed, and functional. Soap dish? Completely fine. Little snack tray? Also fine.
Does Air Dry Clay Need to Be Sealed or Glazed?
Yes, if you want it to be waterproof and durable. Unglazed air dry clay is porous and will absorb moisture over time — fine for a decorative piece on a shelf, but if you want to actually use your tray for anything wet or wash it, sealing is essential. One coat of glaze is all it takes.
Where They Live Now
Both trays are in the kitchen — one holds soap by the sink, one holds little matchboxes on the counter. They brought color and life to a space that honestly needed it, and they have a story attached to them that no store-bought piece ever will. That’s the thing about making something yourself — even if it looks a little like toast.
The Full Cost Breakdown
| Item | Cost |
|---|---|
| Crayola Air Dry Clay 5lb | $13 |
| Clay tool kit | ~$20 |
| Lockmio glaze | included in kit or ~$8 separately |
| Wax paper | $3 |
| Cutting mat | $5 (optional) |
| Winsor & Newton acrylic paint | $28 (or use what you have) |
| Total if buying everything | ~$69 |
| Total essentials only | ~$36 |
My Honest Hot Take on This as a Date Night
Don’t aim for perfection on the first try. If you’re doing this as a date, the experience of two people figuring something out together is the whole point. Imperfect = handmade = unique. My toast cat tray is my favorite thing in the kitchen right now and it looks nothing like what I planned.
The bar for supplies is low, the mess is manageable, and the result is something you actually keep. As far as stay-home dates go, this one earns a strong recommendation from both of us.
Shop This Post
- Crayola Air Dry Clay — Natural White 5lb — $13, beginner friendly, way more than you’ll use in one sitting
- Clay Tool Kit — ~$20, has everything including the essential three
- Lockmio Glaze Kit — seals and waterproofs your finished piece
- Winsor & Newton Acrylic Paint — $28, worth it for the pigment quality
- Wax Paper — $3, essential for keeping clay from sticking
- Cutting Mat — $5, optional unless you’re doing precise knife cuts